Charlotte: Dr. Granville, I can assure you that women enjoy physical pleasure just as much as men, even if it can be hard to come by.
Mortimer: Pleasure has nothing to do with it. It is strictly a medical treatment that stimulates the nervous system.
Charlotte: Indeed it does, and it’s a bargain at a guinea! But my point is, according to your diagnosis, hysteria seems to cover everything from insomnia to toothache. It’s nothing more than a catch-all for dissatisfied women.
This is not an Oscar winner, but Tyler and I watched it the other day and really enjoyed it. He was reluctant, but it won him over.
Warning: If sexual topics make you uncomfortable, don't read on or watch the movie!
The movie is not only hilarious, it is also a fascinating look at the science and medicine of that time period (the late 1800s).
The opening scene shows the main character, Dr. Mortimer Granville (Hugh Dancy), a young, idealistic doctor trying to do some good, working at a hospital with primitive medical practices. Bleeding, leeches, pills that do nothing.
Granville gets into a heated argument with the head doctor about the necessity of changing a bandage on a patient to avoid infection, which the head doctor thinks is nonsense. He tries explaining that otherwise germs cause infection: "Germs. They’re tiny creatures that invade the body." The patient, an elderly lady, says "I don't think I have those," and Granville responds, "You can’t see them. They’re invisible." Everyone stares at him like he's crazy, and you can kind of see why -it did sound a little like science fiction.
He joins the practice of Dr. Robert Dalrymple (Jonathan Pryce), telling him "Sir, I would be enormously grateful for any position that allowed me to offer relief to my patients, with little chance of killing them." He helps Dalrymple treat "hysteria" in women, something that seems to encompass any sort of nervous/dissatisfied complaint that women have, which Dalrymple believes can be cured by "pelvic massage." The men are dopes, and have no idea that they are actually causing female orgasms. There is nothing sexual about it, of course, because "Women are incapable of any physical satisfaction without the insertion of the male organ."
I think a lot of reviewers didn't like the movie, because they were expecting a serious feminist take on the subject, but I think that would have made it uncomfortable to watch. It was the humorous approach to the subject that made it work, in my opinion.
The actors (Hugh Dancy, Rupert Everett, Felicity Jones, Maggie Gyllenhaal, Jonathan Pryce, Sheridan Smith) are all great comic actors.
I would recommend it to anybody not squeamish and looking for a really funny movie.
Granville: It must be difficult pleasuring half the women in the city.
Mortimer: Madame, pleasure has nothing to do with it, I can assure you.
Charlotte: I suppose that depends on whether you're over the table or on it.
I thought that this movie was hilarious. I was shocked when I read some of the reviews saying it was not feminist enough or whatever. I thought that this movie was much more about the buffoonery of medicine back then and I felt that Maggie Gyllenhall was a very strong female character. Did they really want a serious feminist look at the development of the vibrator? Really?
ReplyDeleteAgreed, my love.
ReplyDeleteI also found it very amusing, and well casted. It was hard not to laugh throughout the movie, specially as the doctors were so serious! If they had only asked Maggie about this ailment, she would have set them straight from the beginning, but they would not have made as much money.
ReplyDelete